Best Pickleball Paddles for Intermediate Players: Top Picks & Buying Guide

Why Paddle Choice Matters for Intermediate Players

As an intermediate player, you're no longer just learning the basics. You’ve developed consistency, understand shot techniques, and likely compete in casual or club-level games. The paddle you used as a beginner may now feel too limited—perhaps lacking in power, control, or responsiveness.

Upgrading to a paddle suited for intermediate play helps you:

• Increase shot precision and spin

• Transition smoothly between defensive and offensive strategies

• Reduce fatigue during long matches

• Build confidence in volleys, dinks, and smashes

Let’s look at what makes a great pickleball paddle for intermediate players.

Key Features to Look for in a Paddle

Before diving into our list of the best pickleball paddles for intermediate players, it's important to understand the characteristics that separate an average paddle from a game-changer.

1. Weight

Intermediate players typically benefit from paddles that fall within the 7.5 to 8.3 oz range. Lighter paddles (7.3 oz and below) offer quick maneuverability but can lack power. Heavier paddles (8.5 oz and above) provide strong shots but may cause fatigue or strain.

2. Core Material

Common core types include:

• Polymer (Poly): Offers a good balance of control and power. It’s also quieter, which is great for community courts.

• Nomex: Harder core, producing more power but less control. Often preferred by aggressive players.

• Aluminum: Lightweight and control-focused but may feel softer or less powerful.

Polymer cores are usually the best choice for intermediates.

3. Surface Material

• Graphite: Lightweight and provides excellent ball feel.

• Carbon Fiber: Durable, rigid, and offers superb control and spin.

• Fiberglass (Composite): More pop and power, slightly less control than graphite.

4. Grip Size and Comfort

An ergonomic grip with the correct circumference (typically 4 to 4.5 inches) is essential to avoid wrist strain and enhance shot stability.

5. Paddle Shape

• Standard Shape: Balanced performance.

• Elongated Shape: Longer reach and more power but narrower sweet spot.

• Widebody Shape: Larger sweet spot, ideal for improving accuracy.

Now that we’ve covered the essentials, let’s look at our top picks.

Top 7 Best Pickleball Paddles for Intermediate Players

Here are the best pickleball paddles that cater specifically to intermediate players in 2025.

1. Selkirk Amped S2

Best for: Balanced Control and Power

• Weight: 7.9–8.4 oz

• Core: X5 Polymer Honeycomb

• Surface: FiberFlex Fiberglass

• Shape: Standard

The Selkirk Amped S2 offers an optimal blend of power and control with a large sweet spot, making it perfect for intermediate players transitioning to a more competitive level. The FiberFlex surface improves spin while dampening vibrations.

Pros:

• Comfortable grip

• Durable construction

• Great for all-around play

Cons:

• Slightly expensive

2. JOOLA Ben Johns Hyperion CFS 14

Best for: Spin and Advanced Control

• Weight: 8.2 oz

• Core: Reactive Polymer Honeycomb

• Surface: Carbon Friction Surface (CFS)

• Shape: Elongated

Made famous by top pro Ben Johns, this JOOLA paddle is ideal for intermediate players ready to up their game. The carbon surface enhances spin potential, and the elongated shape gives more reach without compromising control.

Pros:

• Exceptional spin

• Comfortable anti-slip grip

• Ideal for control-focused players

Cons:

• Pricier than entry-level paddles

3. ONIX Z5 Graphite

Best for: Budget-Friendly Performance

• Weight: 7.5–8.2 oz

• Core: Nomex Honeycomb

• Surface: Graphite

• Shape: Widebody

A consistent favorite in the pickleball community, the ONIX Z5 offers power and responsiveness with a solid graphite face and widebody shape. It’s ideal for intermediates looking for a performance boost without breaking the bank.

Pros:

• Great value for money

• Versatile performance

• Lightweight and easy to handle

Cons:

• Less forgiving on off-center hits

4. Paddletek Tempest Wave Pro

Best for: Touch and Control

• Weight: 7.6–8 oz

• Core: High-Grade Polymer Composite Honeycomb

• Surface: Graphite

• Shape: Standard

If finesse is your game, the Tempest Wave Pro is for you. It provides excellent touch and control, helping you dominate the net and execute accurate dinks. Despite its control-focused design, it doesn’t sacrifice too much power.

Pros:

• Precision and feel

• Quiet performance

• Comfortable grip

Cons:

• Not ideal for power hitters

5. Franklin Signature Carbon STK Paddle

Best for: Intermediate to Advanced Transition

• Weight: 7.9–8.3 oz

• Core: Polymer

• Surface: Carbon Fiber

• Shape: Elongated

The Franklin Carbon STK offers premium features like a T700 raw carbon face for maximum spin and control. It's a fantastic choice for intermediates planning to move into advanced competitive play.

Pros:

• High spin potential

• Sleek design

• Durable build

Cons:

• Smaller sweet spot due to elongated design

6. HEAD Radical Elite

Best for: Beginners Moving Into Intermediate Play

• Weight: 8.1 oz

• Core: Composite Honeycomb

• Surface: Fiberglass

• Shape: Standard

A perfect stepping stone from beginner paddles, the HEAD Radical Elite offers a mix of comfort, control, and playability. The fiberglass face ensures added pop while the cushioned grip enhances comfort during longer games.

Pros:

• Affordable

• Lightweight feel

• Great for developing technique

Cons:

• Limited spin potential

7. Engage Encore MX 6.0

Best for: Soft Game and Spin

• Weight: 7.8–8.3 oz

• Core: ControlPro Polymer

• Surface: Specialized Fiber Composite

• Shape: Elongated

Designed with control and soft play in mind, this paddle provides the finesse needed for strategic placements and dinks. It's a favorite among club-level players who prefer a quiet, smooth game.

Pros:

• Large sweet spot

• Excellent touch

• Durable edge guard

Cons:

• May lack power for some players

Tips for Choosing the Right Paddle

Even among the best pickleball paddles for intermediate players, not every paddle will be right for you. Here are some tips to make the best choice:

• Test different paddles before buying—many clubs offer demos.

• Consider your playstyle—do you rely more on power, spin, or finesse?

• Check the warranty—good brands often offer at least a 6–12 month warranty.

• Don’t overspend—there are excellent mid-range paddles between $80–$150.

FAQs About Pickleball Paddles for Intermediate Players

Q1: How do I know if I’m an intermediate pickleball player?

You’re likely intermediate if you:

• Have a consistent serve and return

• Understand basic strategies like dinking and third-shot drops

• Can maintain rallies with moderate pace and direction

• Play regularly and possibly compete in local games or tournaments

Q2: Should I choose a heavier or lighter paddle?

Intermediate players benefit from medium-weight paddles (7.8–8.3 oz) for balance. Heavier paddles provide more power, while lighter ones are better for speed and wrist control. Choose based on your comfort and playstyle.

Q3: Is graphite or carbon fiber better?

Both are great options. Graphite offers excellent ball feel and control. Carbon fiber is slightly stiffer and more durable, giving you enhanced spin and touch. Carbon fiber paddles tend to cost more.

Q4: How often should I replace my paddle?

With regular play (3–4 times per week), a paddle typically lasts 12–18 months. You should replace your paddle if:

• You notice cracks or dents

• The surface becomes smooth and loses grip

• The core feels “dead” or less responsive

Q5: Can intermediate players use pro-level paddles?

Yes, but it’s not always necessary. Pro paddles are often optimized for very specific playstyles and might be less forgiving. Intermediate players should prioritize balance and control before jumping to elite gear.

Conclusion

Finding the best pickleball paddle for intermediate players is all about matching your growing skills with a paddle that complements your evolving game. Whether you prioritize control, spin, power, or all of the above, the right paddle can help you break through plateaus and bring more enjoyment to every match.

From the control-focused Paddletek Tempest Wave Pro to the spin-savvy JOOLA Ben Johns Hyperion, there’s something for every type of intermediate player in this guide. Use this information to test, compare, and ultimately choose a paddle that will take your pickleball journey to the next level.

Happy playing—and see you on the court!